Fifteen-year-old Kayla was last seen on the evening of August 11, 2009 with a 24-year-old friend, Kevin J. Kielcheski, who drove her around her hometown of Antigo, Wisconsin and they allegedly smoked marijuana that night.
Sometime between 9:00 and 11:00 p.m., Kevin dropped Kayla off at her boyfriend's home in Wausau, Wisconsin (which is about a 40 minute drive from Antigo). He stated the house (which is located across the street from the Colonial Manor Nursing Home) had all the lights turned off and it looked as if no one was home.
Kielcheski never actually saw Kayla go inside the house and Kayla has never been heard from again. Kayla was reported missing six days prior to police taking action; her parents had a fairly open living arrangement for her & her younger brother, and they often traveled back and forth by themselves between one parent's house and another.
Kayla, her brother, and her mother had moved to Texas earlier in 2009, but the children were homesick and after just three months, their mother took them and moved back to Wisconsin.
Authorities initially believed that Kayla was a runaway and stated her friends appeared evasive, as if they were trying to conceal her whereabouts; however, police began to reconsider the runaway theory as weeks passed without any contact.
Kayla's boyfriend denied having seen her the day of her disappearance; he is four years older than Kayla and her mother didn't approve of their relationship because of the age difference between them.
The house Kayla went to on the night of her disappearance had actually been condemned and its occupants had moved out while the building was being renovated, but it's unclear whether she knew about this or not.
In October of 2009, Kielcheski was arrested and charged with second-degree reckless endangerment which is related to substance use with Kayla on the night she was last seen. The charge was dismissed in July of 2011 and Kielcheski hasn't been charged or named as a suspect in Kayla's actual disappearance; he is no longer cooperating with the investigation.
Kayla is described as a passionate gymnast who was looking forward to being on her school's team. She didn't own a cell phone or a computer at the time of her disappearance, and apparently didn't use the internet very much.
She has no history of running away from home and it's uncharacteristic of her not to keep her parents informed of her whereabouts. Her nickname is Kay Kay.
Although there is no evidence of foul play in Kayla's case, her mother believes she was abducted. As of 2020, her case remains unsolved.